Skip to main content

Amazing Feedback

At St. Marys Insurance Agency, Inc. & Affiliates, we exceed expectations.

A culture of doing the right things.

Home » About Our Agency » Amazing Feedback

Anyone can promise great service, but not everyone can deliver it. At St. Marys Insurance Agency, Inc. & Affiliates, we’ve built a culture around doing the right things. But don’t just take our word for it. Read these client testimonials to see exactly what we mean.

It is a great insurance company, they have helped me when I needed it.

David Bender

The staff members are always an ace at their job! Questions are answered quickly!

Maggie Bishop

Please talk to Boyle's about life insurance especially for your kids. It's a great gift for them later on in life!

Nicole Carnicella

Adam Fox has been absolutely fantastic to work with. There have been many times that I was in need of last-minute insurance policies and he pulled through. I would highly recommend any insurance you might need you to call him!

Brandy Tressler

Boyles has always been an amazing company to work with for all of our business' insurance needs. We've had some minor and major fender benders and all were handled swiftly and without any trouble by their team.

Nikolas Mataka

Always helpful, very thorough. Great prices and discounts when qualified. Super friendly service.

Dawn

Great service and great rates. I am getting ready to review my policy for the third time. I originally switched to St Marys for the great rate they were able to get me. I'm renewing because the rates remain low, and the service is unbelievable.

Brian Stauffer

Super friendly and helpful, the best choice for the best rates!

Rachel Mateo

These guys have been helping me out with my business insurance needs for years and years. They are professional and easy to deal with! Adam Fox is the best! Thanks for helping to make Top Hat Chimney a great company!

Barb Peters

Mary Sawers

Mike Fielding

Mervyn Stelter
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • 11
  • 12
/12
More Reviews

I am happy with the professional service that we are getting to meet our insurance needs through Cindy Moyer at Boyles Insurance. She is very kind, prompt in responding and providing us the best suggestions. I have not been looking any options for my insurance since 2015, I believe that I am getting the most competitive offer for my needs and I hope Boyles Insurance consider this part. Thanks a lot for the service!

Vaskar & Bandana Thapacustomer since 2014

Sherry has been the biggest help. She went above and beyond to meet my expectations. I will recommend Boyle’s Insurance to everyone!

Morgan Johnsoncustomer since 2021

Kip is ALWAYS great to work with and help us with anything and everything we need. We sure appreciate him! Thanks

Customersince 2007

Sherri is always a please to work with. No mater what I contact her to help me with, she is always more than happy to assist.

Customersince 2003

any time i have needed help with a policy or had a question concerning my policy i was helped immediately. the staff is very kind and knowledgeable. i have never had a hassle/issue getting what i need with boyles insurance.

Customersince 2017

Boyles Insurance has been great to work with and are always responsive.Their personnel are always polite and courteous. Our rates are very competitive.

Customersince 2007

Boyle’s insurance was fantastic after my auto accident. I continually got letter updates plus when I had to call I got prompt answers.

Customersince 2019

Great customer service. I had to submit a claim on my home insurance for water damage and I was very satisfied with the quick service and advice.

Customersince 2007

You saved us close to $800 in premium, for the year, and that is always good!!!

Customersince 2020

always quick responses - easy to get in touch with

Customersince 2018

You always answer my questions in a timely and informative manner.

Peter & Marguerite Carpentercustomer since 2009

Excellent customer service-always!

Customersince 2008

You are always there to answer my questions and are always helpful!

Customersince 2007

Boyles agency always gets me prompt answers and if I have any concerns I always feel confident that they will help put my mind to ease and follow through on items that need follow up.

Lu Baircustomer since 2017

Every time I call the office and need something anyone is very helpful!

Debbie Stachowskicustomer since 2009

Whenever I call, they are always responsive and get whatever Im calling about taken care of quickly and easily.

Customersince 2013

We’ve been beyond impressed with how quickly and professionally you have handled all of our needs! Extremely satisfied with Boyle’s Insurance.

Customersince 2002

Your agents are good at communicating with me about my policies and trying to save me money while making sure I am amply covered for risk. I recently had a major home calamity and your agent and Erie treated me royally. I expected to have to fight and argue for benefits but your folks were more than fair with me and my problem. I have told anyone who will listen that you guys can't be beat. Bravo to you.

Customersince 2008

The service is always prompt and all our insurance needs are taken care of. The staff is helpful, polite, and professional.

Customersince 2006

Customer service is excellent, always nice, patient and helpful. They give us the feeling that they really care and always go the extra mile. Very happy having Boyles as our agent. Thank you from both of us!!

Kathryn Bullingtoncustomer since 2008

What I really like about your company is that I always feel like I am priority......even when I'm not. Thank you for making me feel like I have a friend when I contact you. Great job!

Customersince 2018

It has always been easy to work with this agency. I have been with them for a long time and in that time I bought a house and changed vehicles several times. I never had a problem.

Customersince 2007

Saved me money. Easy transition from State Farm to Boyle’s insurance.

Customersince 2007

The service provided by Boyles (St. Mary's Insurance Agency) is outstanding. Any time we have a question about our policy or need to update anything, the response time is exceptional and handled in a professional manner.

Customersince 2007

Great Service!!! My family has used this office for many years.

Catherine Mainescustomer since 2005

Boyles Insurance Agency has consistently offered me good rates and great customer service.

Customersince 2016

Always have the best quotes and great customer service

Customersince 2011

Always there when needed

Russell Krisecustomer since 2007

Jim is always very courteous and if I have any problems he is always there to help.

Mary Carlsoncustomer since 2016

ALWAYS polite , professional, and timely. They go the extra mile to make sure I have the best coverage for my money. They will always have my trust and my business. They have never led me astray and have always been there to help.

Gary Gallahercustomer since 2005

I don't call your office very often, but when I do, everyone there is more than willing to help me (no matter if it is just a trivial question). I appreciate the friendly help I get from your office.

Customersince 2013

Always quick to answer any questions and always there when needed!

Ronnie Jurycustomer since 2007

The staff at Boyles Insurance is always very responsive to my questions and policy changes. Lately, I've made many changes to both my auto and homeowner's policies, and Boyles has made those changes quickly and effectively. Plus, they have recently reduced premiums for many of their policies, an added and very welcome bonus!

Customersince 2007

Have always received fast and courteous response when questioning my coverage and recommendations for my account. I can trust this agency to have my best interest at stake and although I have been quoted a better price for same coverage from another brand name company, I am not likely to change because of my past dealings.

Robert Lopecustomer since 2007

Conscientious, thorough, and personable!

Gabriela Winqvistcustomer since 2011

They are courteous, dependable, and friendly. If I need help with something they are always willing and able.

Customersince 2006

Get tasks accomplished in a timely manner. Also always keep me updated

Customersince 2018

I really appreciate the rapid attention and quick resolution of all my car and house insurance needs. Been with Boyles since 2007 and have been so pleased.

Andrew Readcustomer since 2007

Sherri has been an exceptional agent, patiently and thoroughly explaining policy details and listening carefully to our needs. In addition, she always makes herself available to discuss anything at all. We are very pleased with Erie, our coverage, and our agent!

Customersince 2017

Prompt service, very friendly,competitive pricing,

James Bailorcustomer since 2007

I appreciate that Sherry is very quick and competent with her responses to any question I ask her....and I have asked a lot...lol!

Customersince 2009

Linda Lang always replies to me within a few hours of me emailing her. She is great at handling any issues I have and I always feel like I am prioritized.

Customersince 2018

My last insurance for my house was doubled when the company was bought out and they thought I had to accept it. I said I didn;t and called yours since my car ins. was there. I was met with open arms and got a better plan and cheeper Thank you

Donna Shawcustomer since 2007

Your office is always very prompt when answering questions, and in general are great to work with!

Customersince 2016

Linda Lang was enormously helpful while I was researching insurance product options and again when I was in the stressful position of having to file a claim. She's been unfailingly kind and helpful and very quick with responses to all my questions. I used to have coverage with a faceless national company, but I've had top notch customer service every step of the way.

Elizabeth Welshcustomer since 2019

Wonderful and helpful staff

Nichole Yinglingcustomer since 2019

Whenever I call and need anything it is done right away. I needed a copy of my homeowners sent to my bank to finish a refinance and it was done immediately. I also needed to add a vehicle to our policy and the follow up was amazing.

Kasey Schiano & Luciano Schinao Di Colacustomer since 2011

You've always been so helpful even though we have a lot of different insurance needs.

Customersince 2011

When we call or stop by the office everyone is friendly and committed to helping. If we have questions, the answers are replied to in a timely fashion and are easy to understand. The two claims we have had during the past 3.5 years have been a super positive experience. Erie has proven to our family that they are committed to customer service. Thank you.

Customersince 2007

Anytime I call they answer my questions or concerns quickly and concisely.

Customersince 2007

They were very accommodating during a rough time and set everything up the way I needed it to be.

Customersince 2020

Fast response when I had a claim and follow up to make sure everything is taken care of.

Daren Pentzcustomer since 2007

They are always easy to get a hold of and answer your questions quickly.

Shari Lynn Farnethcustomer since 2007

I have used Boyle's insurance for many, many years Even when I moved out of the area, I have continued to use Boyle's for my insurance needs. Sherry Wood is always very knowledgeable, courteous and quick to reply whenever I have changes to be made or questions about my policies.

Sherri Owenscustomer since 1986

you listen to my requests and are responsive and courteous. There has never been an error with any change or addition I've ask you to make to my policies. I've been with you all for over 10 years

Zane Shermancustomer since 2010

Sherry is always prompt, knowledgeable and kind in her responses to any question I may have. I work with her from a longer distance than most, and she still is able to answer questions and get me the coverage I need.

Customersince 2016

Make it nice and easy to get great car insurance and renters insurance

Customersince 2015

Customer service is always excellent. Employees are helpful and quick to respond to emails and calls. I’ve never had an issue with Boyle’s.

Mikayla Gunsalluscustomer since 2013

Sherry has been my agent for 20 years and is always there when needed!

Customersince 2007

Customer service is amazing with their willingness to answer any questions I had even if the question seemed mundane in nature. Will to help guide a new policy owner through the steps to create a fitting policy that fits them.

Customersince 2020

Great Team to work with! Best and Fast service All the time!

Customersince 2015

any of my questions and or concerns are answered promptly. any questions or concerns have been answered in a prompt and friendly manner.

Customersince 2016

Never had an issue getting information we needed. There were times when the information was needed ASAP— Boyles responded quickly. Also love the friendly staff-very easy to do business with.

Michael Baumcustomer since 2007

Took very good care of me when adding cars to my policy. Thank you

Customersince 2012

My agent did an excellent job of presenting our insurance proposal but the most important thing that he does. He has given us continuous support for the past two years in order to make sure that our business is properly covered now and for the future. Very professional and shows that he cares for his client. For this reason, we are bringing our business to you for our next restaurant this month. Thanks!! Pete Hess

Peter Shahcustomer since 2018

Boyles has always been great. I have been using them for my car insurance for over 20 years and continued to use them even after I moved away due to the great service. When I bought my house, Sherry was extremely helpful navigating home owners policy options. Great service!

Customersince 2008

You always answer any questions I have - you get back to me when I call, and your always courteous.

Roxanne Barzonacustomer since 1992

Everything is always hassle free!

Courtney Woostercustomer since 1997

I am happy with the professional service that we are getting to meet our insurance needs through Cindy Moyer at Boyles Insurance. She is very kind, prompt in responding and providing us the best suggestions. I have not been looking any options for my insurance since 2015, I believe that I am getting the most competitive offer for my needs and I hope Boyles Insurance consider this part. Thanks a lot for the service!

Vaskar & Bandana Thapacustomer since 2014

Sherry has been the biggest help. She went above and beyond to meet my expectations. I will recommend Boyle’s Insurance to everyone!

Morgan Johnsoncustomer since 2021

Kip is ALWAYS great to work with and help us with anything and everything we need. We sure appreciate him! Thanks

Customersince 2007

Sherri is always a please to work with. No mater what I contact her to help me with, she is always more than happy to assist.

Customersince 2003

any time i have needed help with a policy or had a question concerning my policy i was helped immediately. the staff is very kind and knowledgeable. i have never had a hassle/issue getting what i need with boyles insurance.

Customersince 2017

Boyles Insurance has been great to work with and are always responsive.Their personnel are always polite and courteous. Our rates are very competitive.

Customersince 2007

Boyle’s insurance was fantastic after my auto accident. I continually got letter updates plus when I had to call I got prompt answers.

Customersince 2019

Great customer service. I had to submit a claim on my home insurance for water damage and I was very satisfied with the quick service and advice.

Customersince 2007

You saved us close to $800 in premium, for the year, and that is always good!!!

Customersince 2020

always quick responses - easy to get in touch with

Customersince 2018

You always answer my questions in a timely and informative manner.

Peter & Marguerite Carpentercustomer since 2009

Excellent customer service-always!

Customersince 2008

You are always there to answer my questions and are always helpful!

Customersince 2007

Boyles agency always gets me prompt answers and if I have any concerns I always feel confident that they will help put my mind to ease and follow through on items that need follow up.

Lu Baircustomer since 2017

Every time I call the office and need something anyone is very helpful!

Debbie Stachowskicustomer since 2009

Whenever I call, they are always responsive and get whatever Im calling about taken care of quickly and easily.

Customersince 2013

We’ve been beyond impressed with how quickly and professionally you have handled all of our needs! Extremely satisfied with Boyle’s Insurance.

Customersince 2002

Your agents are good at communicating with me about my policies and trying to save me money while making sure I am amply covered for risk. I recently had a major home calamity and your agent and Erie treated me royally. I expected to have to fight and argue for benefits but your folks were more than fair with me and my problem. I have told anyone who will listen that you guys can't be beat. Bravo to you.

Customersince 2008

The service is always prompt and all our insurance needs are taken care of. The staff is helpful, polite, and professional.

Customersince 2006

Customer service is excellent, always nice, patient and helpful. They give us the feeling that they really care and always go the extra mile. Very happy having Boyles as our agent. Thank you from both of us!!

Kathryn Bullingtoncustomer since 2008

What I really like about your company is that I always feel like I am priority......even when I'm not. Thank you for making me feel like I have a friend when I contact you. Great job!

Customersince 2018

It has always been easy to work with this agency. I have been with them for a long time and in that time I bought a house and changed vehicles several times. I never had a problem.

Customersince 2007

Saved me money. Easy transition from State Farm to Boyle’s insurance.

Customersince 2007

The service provided by Boyles (St. Mary's Insurance Agency) is outstanding. Any time we have a question about our policy or need to update anything, the response time is exceptional and handled in a professional manner.

Customersince 2007

Great Service!!! My family has used this office for many years.

Catherine Mainescustomer since 2005

Boyles Insurance Agency has consistently offered me good rates and great customer service.

Customersince 2016

Always have the best quotes and great customer service

Customersince 2011

Always there when needed

Russell Krisecustomer since 2007

Jim is always very courteous and if I have any problems he is always there to help.

Mary Carlsoncustomer since 2016

ALWAYS polite , professional, and timely. They go the extra mile to make sure I have the best coverage for my money. They will always have my trust and my business. They have never led me astray and have always been there to help.

Gary Gallahercustomer since 2005

I don't call your office very often, but when I do, everyone there is more than willing to help me (no matter if it is just a trivial question). I appreciate the friendly help I get from your office.

Customersince 2013

Always quick to answer any questions and always there when needed!

Ronnie Jurycustomer since 2007

The staff at Boyles Insurance is always very responsive to my questions and policy changes. Lately, I've made many changes to both my auto and homeowner's policies, and Boyles has made those changes quickly and effectively. Plus, they have recently reduced premiums for many of their policies, an added and very welcome bonus!

Customersince 2007

Have always received fast and courteous response when questioning my coverage and recommendations for my account. I can trust this agency to have my best interest at stake and although I have been quoted a better price for same coverage from another brand name company, I am not likely to change because of my past dealings.

Robert Lopecustomer since 2007

Conscientious, thorough, and personable!

Gabriela Winqvistcustomer since 2011

They are courteous, dependable, and friendly. If I need help with something they are always willing and able.

Customersince 2006

Get tasks accomplished in a timely manner. Also always keep me updated

Customersince 2018

I really appreciate the rapid attention and quick resolution of all my car and house insurance needs. Been with Boyles since 2007 and have been so pleased.

Andrew Readcustomer since 2007

Sherri has been an exceptional agent, patiently and thoroughly explaining policy details and listening carefully to our needs. In addition, she always makes herself available to discuss anything at all. We are very pleased with Erie, our coverage, and our agent!

Customersince 2017

Prompt service, very friendly,competitive pricing,

James Bailorcustomer since 2007

I appreciate that Sherry is very quick and competent with her responses to any question I ask her....and I have asked a lot...lol!

Customersince 2009

Linda Lang always replies to me within a few hours of me emailing her. She is great at handling any issues I have and I always feel like I am prioritized.

Customersince 2018

My last insurance for my house was doubled when the company was bought out and they thought I had to accept it. I said I didn;t and called yours since my car ins. was there. I was met with open arms and got a better plan and cheeper Thank you

Donna Shawcustomer since 2007

Your office is always very prompt when answering questions, and in general are great to work with!

Customersince 2016

Linda Lang was enormously helpful while I was researching insurance product options and again when I was in the stressful position of having to file a claim. She's been unfailingly kind and helpful and very quick with responses to all my questions. I used to have coverage with a faceless national company, but I've had top notch customer service every step of the way.

Elizabeth Welshcustomer since 2019

Wonderful and helpful staff

Nichole Yinglingcustomer since 2019

Whenever I call and need anything it is done right away. I needed a copy of my homeowners sent to my bank to finish a refinance and it was done immediately. I also needed to add a vehicle to our policy and the follow up was amazing.

Kasey Schiano & Luciano Schinao Di Colacustomer since 2011

You've always been so helpful even though we have a lot of different insurance needs.

Customersince 2011

When we call or stop by the office everyone is friendly and committed to helping. If we have questions, the answers are replied to in a timely fashion and are easy to understand. The two claims we have had during the past 3.5 years have been a super positive experience. Erie has proven to our family that they are committed to customer service. Thank you.

Customersince 2007

Anytime I call they answer my questions or concerns quickly and concisely.

Customersince 2007

They were very accommodating during a rough time and set everything up the way I needed it to be.

Customersince 2020

Fast response when I had a claim and follow up to make sure everything is taken care of.

Daren Pentzcustomer since 2007

They are always easy to get a hold of and answer your questions quickly.

Shari Lynn Farnethcustomer since 2007

I have used Boyle's insurance for many, many years Even when I moved out of the area, I have continued to use Boyle's for my insurance needs. Sherry Wood is always very knowledgeable, courteous and quick to reply whenever I have changes to be made or questions about my policies.

Sherri Owenscustomer since 1986

you listen to my requests and are responsive and courteous. There has never been an error with any change or addition I've ask you to make to my policies. I've been with you all for over 10 years

Zane Shermancustomer since 2010

Sherry is always prompt, knowledgeable and kind in her responses to any question I may have. I work with her from a longer distance than most, and she still is able to answer questions and get me the coverage I need.

Customersince 2016

Make it nice and easy to get great car insurance and renters insurance

Customersince 2015

Customer service is always excellent. Employees are helpful and quick to respond to emails and calls. I’ve never had an issue with Boyle’s.

Mikayla Gunsalluscustomer since 2013

Sherry has been my agent for 20 years and is always there when needed!

Customersince 2007

Customer service is amazing with their willingness to answer any questions I had even if the question seemed mundane in nature. Will to help guide a new policy owner through the steps to create a fitting policy that fits them.

Customersince 2020

Great Team to work with! Best and Fast service All the time!

Customersince 2015

any of my questions and or concerns are answered promptly. any questions or concerns have been answered in a prompt and friendly manner.

Customersince 2016

Never had an issue getting information we needed. There were times when the information was needed ASAP— Boyles responded quickly. Also love the friendly staff-very easy to do business with.

Michael Baumcustomer since 2007

Took very good care of me when adding cars to my policy. Thank you

Customersince 2012

My agent did an excellent job of presenting our insurance proposal but the most important thing that he does. He has given us continuous support for the past two years in order to make sure that our business is properly covered now and for the future. Very professional and shows that he cares for his client. For this reason, we are bringing our business to you for our next restaurant this month. Thanks!! Pete Hess

Peter Shahcustomer since 2018

Boyles has always been great. I have been using them for my car insurance for over 20 years and continued to use them even after I moved away due to the great service. When I bought my house, Sherry was extremely helpful navigating home owners policy options. Great service!

Customersince 2008

You always answer any questions I have - you get back to me when I call, and your always courteous.

Roxanne Barzonacustomer since 1992

Everything is always hassle free!

Courtney Woostercustomer since 1997
About Our Agency - Happy Baby Touching Grandfathers Face With Family Outside

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote

  Request an Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

It only takes a minute to get started.

  • Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
  • Go over your options with an agent.
  • Get the coverage you need.

Would you rather discuss this in person? Get in touch with an agent today!